Investigators are processing evidence and sifting through stolen retail property that was being traded from a storefront in West Rome. The proprietor of the store has been arrested and is being held in jail without bond for the thefts that extend into several jurisdictions.

The Floyd County Police Department was on site at West Rome Trading Company for more than 20 hours while investigators sorted and collected evidence from a search warrant that was served Thursday night at the store on Shorter Avenue. Loss prevention officers were also on site with scanners to confirm and recover property from retailers that include Home Depot, Walmart, Academy Sports, Lowe’s and
Dunham’s Sport.

Earl Lamar Renfroe Jr, 42, has been charged with theft by receiving stolen property and conspiracy to commit a theft; both offenses are felonies. The value of stolen property that has been calculated so far is $87,057, including 84 baseball bats valued at $23,063.

Evidence found at the scene may also include property stolen from burglaries and thefts. Jeff Jones, commander of the investigative division for FCPD, said there is a “very high probability” that there is stolen property in the store that was traded from crimes in this area. Items that have been recovered include: tools, cameras, lawn equipment, GPS equipment, televisions, tooth brushes and maternity supplies.

The Cartersville Police Department was first to make an arrest outside their Home Depot and contact the Floyd County Police Department. Evidence obtained from that traffic stop helped investigators track down property that was stolen from retailers and traded at West Rome Trading Company.

Our local investigators coordinated with loss prevention officers from a variety of retailers, but much of the stolen property still had stickers and price tags from the locations from where it was stolen. Police believe property found at West Rome Trading Company was stolen from not only surrounding counties but also Marietta and Hiram.

The investigation is ongoing but police believe stolen property was being sold locally from the storefront and also in online marketplaces. It is likely that crimes occurring at the store stretched to other locations across state lines.

The recovery of evidence is thanks to assistance from Cartersville Police Department and the Rome-Floyd Metro Task Force.

Anyone with information is encouraged to contact Floyd County Police Department by calling Sgt. Jordan Clayton at 706-314-1861 or email [email protected]


For the second time in less than a year and a half the manager of the West Rome Trading Post, Earl Lamar Renfroe Jr, 42 of Rome, has been arrested. The latest comes from a report that says he purchased items that he knew were stolen.  Renfroe also made a list with the seller of those items that he wished to attain in the future.

The items that were stolen are valued at over $1,500.  

Renfroe is charged with conspiracy to commit a felony and felony theft by receiving stolen property.

PREVIOUS : October 2020

Earl Lamar Renfroe Jr, 40 of Rome, while operating the West Rome Trading Company on Shorter Avenue was arrested this week after reports said he retained stolen property that was valued at over $6700.

Reports said that the stolen items, Blackstar Amp Head, Peavy Triple X Amp, Les Paul Cherry Gibson guitar, assorted cables, sure fire microphone, Xenyx Beringer, Fender Delux Starburst Telecaster, Lithium battery porter cable, chargers, cordless power cable drills, and a B52 amp.

Authorities went on to say that the items were valued at somewhere between $6,775 to $7,325.

The incident occurred back on October 1.

Renfroe is charged with felony theft by receiving stolen property.